In Arizona, real estate brokerages must comply with state laws and regulations governing record retention, including those for electronic communications such as text messages. These requirements are designed to ensure transparency, accountability, and regulatory oversight in real estate transactions.

1. Record Retention Requirements

Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.) §32-2151.01

• This statute outlines the record retention obligations for real estate brokers:

  • Brokers must retain all records related to a real estate transaction for at least five years from the date of execution or termination of the transaction.

Arizona Administrative Code (A.A.C.) R4-28-802

• Brokers must keep records that are complete and accurate for any transaction or activity performed on behalf of a client, including:

  • Contracts.

  • Correspondence.

  • Documents related to offers, counteroffers, and negotiations.

2. Applicability to Text Messages:

A Text Message as a Legal Record

Under A.R.S. 32-2151.01(A), a licensed employing broker is required to keep records of all transactions handled by or through the broker. The statute does not limit the form of such records to specific mediums, indicating that any documentation that memorializes a transaction is sufficient.

 

According to Black’s Law Dictionary (4th Ed.), a record is a written account of an act or transaction, intended to serve as permanent evidence of the matter. A transaction includes the act of conducting any business, negotiation, or proceeding. An act involves the expression of will or performance of a deed.

 

A text message that documents or discusses a real estate transaction meets these legal definitions:

• It is a written account of a transaction.

• It serves as evidence of the act of transacting or conducting business.

• It reflects an affirmative expression of will between parties involved in a transaction.

 

Since A.R.S. 32-2151.01(A) mandates brokers to keep records of transactions and the legal definitions confirm that a record includes any written memorialization of a transaction, a text message concerning a transaction qualifies as a legal record and is subject to statutory record-keeping requirements.

Examples of relevant text message content:

• Discussions about offers or counteroffers.

• Confirmation of disclosures or contract terms.

• Client instructions or consent.

Text messages that are part of the transaction process must be retained like other correspondence or communications.

3. Broker Responsibility

A.A.C. R4-28-1103

• Brokers are responsible for supervising their licensed agents and ensuring compliance with all record retention requirements.

• This includes implementing systems to capture and archive communications such as emails and text messages.

4. Retention Period

• Five Years: Brokers must retain all transaction-related records, including electronic communications like text messages, for five years from the termination of the transaction or the execution of the document, whichever is later.

5. Risks of Non-Compliance

Failure to retain transaction-related text messages can result in:

1. Regulatory Penalties:

   • Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) may impose fines or sanctions for record-keeping violations.

2. Legal Exposure:

   • Missing records can weaken a broker’s defense in disputes, complaints, or lawsuits.

3. E&O Insurance Issues:

   • Lack of proper documentation can lead to exclusions or denials of Errors & Omissions (E&O) coverage.

6. Best Practices for Compliance

To comply with Arizona's record retention laws, brokerages should:

1. Implement Archiving Solutions:

   • Use technology to automatically archive electronic communications, including text messages.

   • Ensure archived messages are secure, searchable, and retrievable for at least five years.

2. Establish Policies:

   • Require agents to use brokerage-approved systems or tools for all client communications.

   • Clearly define what types of communications must be retained.

3. Train Agents:

   • Educate agents on the importance of retaining transaction-related communications, including texts.

4. Audit Records Regularly:

   • Periodically review records to ensure compliance with retention requirements.

7. Summary

Under A.R.S. §32-2151.01 and A.A.C. R4-28-802, Arizona real estate brokerages must retain all transaction-related records, including text messages, for five years. Brokers are responsible for ensuring compliance through supervision and the implementation of record retention systems. Failure to archive and retain text messages can lead to regulatory penalties, legal exposure, and insurance coverage issues. To mitigate risks, brokerages should adopt comprehensive archiving tools and establish clear policies for managing electronic communications.

​

Brokerage E&O Risk

In Arizona, real estate brokerages are required to retain transaction-related records, including electronic communications such as text messages, for at least five years under A.R.S. §32-2151.01. Failure to archive and retain these messages can expose brokerages to Errors and Omissions (E&O) insurance risks, potentially resulting in denial of coverage. Here's an overview of the key risks and exclusions:

1. Failure to Meet Legal and Regulatory Obligations

Risk:

• Arizona law mandates that brokerages retain all transaction-related records, including text messages. If a brokerage fails to comply with these requirements, it may be deemed in violation of state regulations.

E&O Exclusion:

• Most E&O policies exclude claims arising from illegal or non-compliant practices, such as violations of record-keeping laws. Failure to retain required records, including text messages, may void coverage.

2. Inability to Substantiate Claims or Defenses

Risk:

• In disputes involving a transaction, text messages are often critical evidence. Missing messages can undermine the brokerage's ability to:

  • Prove compliance with disclosure requirements.

  • Defend against allegations of negligence or misrepresentation.

  • Substantiate client instructions or approvals.

E&O Exclusion:

• Many policies require the insured to cooperate fully and provide documentation to substantiate their defense. If essential text messages are unavailable, the insurer may deny coverage under the "failure to cooperate" clause.

3. Allegations of Negligence or Misrepresentation

Risk:

• Clients may claim that a brokerage failed to disclose material facts, misrepresented terms, or did not act in their best interest. Without archived text messages to prove otherwise, the brokerage's defense is weakened.

E&O Exclusion:

• Insurers may exclude coverage for claims where there is insufficient documentation to refute allegations of negligence, misrepresentation, or failure to disclose.

4. Claims of Fraud or Misconduct

Risk:

• If missing text messages are discovered during litigation or investigation, it may raise questions about the brokerage's conduct, including allegations of fraud, concealment, or bad faith.

E&O Exclusion:

• E&O policies universally exclude coverage for claims involving fraud, dishonesty, or intentional wrongdoing. Even unintentional loss of records can create the appearance of misconduct, leading to denial of coverage.

5. Breach of Contract

Risk:

• Real estate contracts often require brokers to document and retain all communications related to the transaction. Failure to retain text messages may constitute a breach of contractual obligations, especially if such messages contain critical terms or agreements.

E&O Exclusion:

• Many policies exclude claims arising from a breach of contract, particularly if the breach involves failure to meet record-keeping obligations.

6. Increased Exposure in Regulatory Investigations

Risk:

• Missing text messages can result in penalties or findings of non-compliance during audits by the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE). This can lead to increased scrutiny, fines, or additional claims.

E&O Exclusion:

• E&O policies typically do not cover fines, penalties, or costs associated with regulatory investigations, especially if non-compliance with laws contributed to the investigation.

7. Supervision and Oversight Failures

Risk:

• Arizona brokers are required to supervise their agents and ensure compliance with record retention laws. If an agent fails to archive text messages, the broker may be held accountable for lack of oversight.

E&O Exclusion:

• Many policies exclude claims arising from failure to supervise employees or agents, particularly if poor supervision contributed to the loss of required records.

Examples of Scenarios Leading to Denial of Coverage

1. Missing Negotiation Records:

   • A client alleges that critical terms were agreed upon via text, but the brokerage cannot produce the messages. Without evidence, the insurer may deny coverage, citing insufficient documentation to support the defense.

2. Disclosure Dispute:

   • A buyer claims the brokerage failed to disclose a material defect. Text messages confirming the disclosure are unavailable, leading to increased liability and a potential coverage denial.

3. Regulatory Violation:

   • During an ADRE audit, the brokerage is found non-compliant with record retention laws. Resulting claims may be excluded due to violations of state regulations.

4. Alleged Misrepresentation:

   • A client accuses the brokerage of misrepresenting terms in a transaction. Missing text messages undermine the defense, and the insurer excludes coverage for lack of cooperation or documentation.

How to Mitigate E&O Risks

To avoid coverage denials and ensure compliance, Arizona brokerages should adopt the following best practices:

1. Implement Text Message Archiving Solutions:

   • Use software to automatically capture and store all transaction-related text messages securely for the required five-year retention period.

2. Establish Clear Communication Policies:

   • Require agents to use approved platforms or tools for all transaction-related communications.

   • Prohibit the use of personal devices or apps that are not part of the brokerage’s archiving system.

3. Train Agents and Staff:

   • Provide regular training on record retention laws and the importance of archiving text messages.

4. Audit Compliance Regularly:

   • Conduct periodic reviews of agent communications to ensure compliance with state laws and brokerage policies.

5. Maintain Documentation:

   • Keep written policies and evidence of compliance efforts to strengthen defenses in case of disputes or regulatory investigations.

Conclusion

Failure to archive and retain text messages exposes Arizona real estate brokerages to significant E&O risks, including denial of coverage due to non-compliance with legal requirements, inability to substantiate defenses, or allegations of negligence. By implementing robust communication policies and archiving systems, brokerages can reduce these risks and protect their E&O coverage.

Risk Mitigation Strategies for Brokerages

To mitigate these risks, brokerages should:

• Establish a clear policy for retaining all relevant electronic communications, including text messages, emails, and digital correspondence, and ensure all agents are trained to comply.

• Invest in archiving technology that captures and stores electronic communications in a secure, accessible, and compliant manner.

• Regularly audit compliance with record-keeping policies to ensure agents are properly retaining required communications and that records are easily retrievable.

• Work closely with E&O providers to understand the requirements and best practices for documentation to ensure comprehensive coverage.

By maintaining thorough, organized records of all communications, including text messages, a brokerage can better protect itself against claims, demonstrate regulatory compliance, and strengthen its defensibility if claims arise, thereby optimizing its E&O insurance coverage and reducing the risk of adverse financial consequences.

​

Memo2File is specifically designed for real estate agents and brokers to properly archive and retain text messages related to a transaction.  

​​

Sample: Text Archive for Real Estate