In Pennsylvania, real estate brokerages are required to maintain comprehensive records of transactions, including communications such as text messages, if they pertain to real estate transactions. The state's regulations align with federal standards to ensure transparency, accountability, and compliance.

1. Record Retention Requirements

A. Pennsylvania Real Estate Licensing and Registration Act (RELRA)

• RELRA (§ 455.606a) requires brokers to retain records related to real estate transactions for a period of three years following the consummation of the transaction.

• This includes all written and electronic communications that relate to the transaction, such as:

  • Offers and counteroffers.

  • Client instructions.

  • Terms and conditions of agreements.

B. Pennsylvania State Real Estate Commission Regulations

• The State Real Estate Commission enforces rules related to record-keeping. Under 49 Pa. Code § 35.286, brokers must:

  • Maintain complete and accurate records of all transactions.

  • Retain all documents, contracts, and communications related to brokerage activities.

C. Applicability to Text Messages

• While Pennsylvania law does not specifically mention "text messages," it requires retention of all relevant correspondence. Text messages that:

  • Convey material terms or agreements,

  • Include client instructions or approvals,

  • or relate to negotiations,

  are considered part of the transaction record and must be archived.

2. Retention Period

• Brokers must retain records for three years from the date of consummation or termination of the transaction.

• Records may be retained in electronic format if they are accessible and can be reproduced for auditing or legal purposes.

3. Electronic Communications and Compliance

A. Use of Technology

• Pennsylvania encourages the use of technology to manage records. However, brokers must ensure:

  • Text messages and other electronic communications are preserved accurately.

  • Communications are stored securely to prevent loss or unauthorized access.

B. Advertising Rules (49 Pa. Code § 35.301)

• If text messages are used for advertising, they must comply with advertising regulations, including:

  • Clear identification of the brokerage.

  • Accurate and truthful representations of properties or services.

  • Retention of advertising records for audit purposes.

4. Broker Responsibility

A. Supervision of Agents (49 Pa. Code § 35.283)

• Brokers are responsible for supervising their agents and ensuring compliance with record retention requirements.

• This includes implementing systems to capture and archive text messages and other electronic communications.

B. Risk of Non-Compliance

• Failure to retain required records, including text messages, can result in:

  • Disciplinary action by the Pennsylvania State Real Estate Commission.

  • Fines or sanctions for violations of RELRA or Commission regulations.

5. Best Practices for Compliance

To comply with Pennsylvania's record retention laws, brokerages should:

1. Adopt Archiving Solutions:

   • Use technology to automatically archive text messages and other electronic communications.

   • Ensure the system can securely store records for the required three-year period.

2. Establish Policies:

   • Require agents to use approved communication platforms that support archiving.

   • Train agents on the importance of retaining transaction-related communications.

3. Audit Records Regularly:

   • Conduct periodic reviews to verify that all required records are being properly archived.

6. Risks of Non-Compliance

Failure to retain transaction-related text messages can lead to:

1. Regulatory Penalties:

   • The Pennsylvania State Real Estate Commission may impose fines or sanctions for non-compliance.

2. Legal Exposure:

   • Missing records can weaken defenses in disputes, complaints, or lawsuits.

3. E&O Insurance Denials:

   • Lack of documentation can result in exclusions or denials of coverage in Errors & Omissions (E&O) claims.

Summary

In Pennsylvania, real estate brokerages must retain all transaction-related records, including text messages, for three years under RELRA and Commission regulations. Text messages that pertain to offers, negotiations, client instructions, or advertising are subject to these requirements. To mitigate risks and ensure compliance, brokerages should implement robust archiving solutions, establish clear communication policies, and conduct regular audits. Failure to retain such records can result in regulatory penalties, legal exposure, and E&O insurance risks.

​

Key E&O Risks and Exclusions

1. Failure to Meet Legal and Regulatory Obligations

• Risk: Pennsylvania law requires the retention of transaction-related records, including electronic communications like text messages. Non-compliance with these requirements can lead to disciplinary actions or legal claims.

• E&O Exclusion: Many policies exclude coverage for claims resulting from violations of laws or regulations. Failure to retain text messages as required by RELRA and state real estate commission regulations may void coverage for related claims.

2. Lack of Documentation to Support Defense

• Risk: If a claim arises and relevant text messages are missing, the brokerage may lack evidence to defend itself against allegations of negligence, misrepresentation, or failure to disclose.

• E&O Exclusion: Insurers may deny coverage under the "failure to cooperate" clause if the brokerage cannot provide sufficient documentation to substantiate its defense.

3. Allegations of Misrepresentation or Negligence

• Risk: Claims of misrepresentation, failure to disclose, or negligence are common in real estate disputes. Text messages often contain critical information about offers, counteroffers, or client approvals, and their absence can weaken the brokerage’s case.

• E&O Exclusion: If the brokerage cannot produce relevant records, insurers may exclude claims for:

  • Negligence due to lack of evidence.

  • Misrepresentation if there’s insufficient proof to refute client accusations.

4. Breach of Contract Claims

• Risk: Missing text messages can result in allegations that the brokerage failed to fulfill contractual obligations, such as delivering disclosures or documenting agreements with clients.

• E&O Exclusion: Many policies exclude coverage for contractual liability claims, especially if the absence of records hinders the defense.

5. Regulatory Violations

• Risk: The Pennsylvania State Real Estate Commission may investigate brokerages for compliance with RELRA record-keeping requirements. Missing text messages can result in fines, sanctions, or increased scrutiny.

• E&O Exclusion: E&O policies generally do not cover:

  • Fines, penalties, or costs associated with regulatory investigations.

  • Claims stemming from non-compliance with record retention laws.

6. Appearance of Fraud or Misconduct

• Risk: The absence of text messages in disputes or audits may raise questions about whether records were intentionally destroyed or concealed, leading to allegations of bad faith or fraud.

• E&O Exclusion: Claims involving fraud, dishonesty, or intentional acts are universally excluded from E&O coverage. Even unintentional loss of records could trigger these exclusions if it creates the appearance of misconduct.

7. Supervision and Oversight Failures

• Risk: Pennsylvania law requires brokers to supervise their agents, including ensuring compliance with record retention requirements. Missing text messages may indicate poor supervision, exposing the brokerage to liability.

• E&O Exclusion: Many policies exclude claims stemming from failure to supervise agents or employees, particularly if inadequate supervision contributed to missing records.

Examples of Scenarios Leading to E&O Coverage Denial

1. Dispute Over Contract Terms:

   • A buyer claims the brokerage misrepresented key contract terms. Text messages confirming the buyer's understanding are missing, leading to denial of coverage due to insufficient documentation.

2. Regulatory Investigation:

   • The Pennsylvania State Real Estate Commission conducts an audit and finds the brokerage non-compliant with record retention requirements. Resulting claims are excluded because they stem from a regulatory violation.

3. Disclosure Dispute:

   • A seller alleges that the brokerage failed to disclose material information via text. Without the archived messages to prove disclosure, the insurer denies coverage due to lack of evidence.

4. Client Instructions:

   • A client disputes an action taken by the brokerage, claiming they never approved it. The brokerage cannot produce text messages showing client consent, leading to coverage denial under the cooperation clause.

Best Practices to Avoid E&O Risks

To mitigate the risk of E&O coverage denial, Pennsylvania brokerages should:

1. Adopt Text Message Archiving Solutions like Memo2File:

   • Use systems to automatically capture and store all transaction-related text messages securely for at least three years.

2. Establish Policies for Communication:

   • Require agents to use approved platforms or tools for all client interactions.0

3. Provide Training to Agents:

   • Educate agents on record retention laws and the importance of retaining text messages.

   • Emphasize how missing records can lead to legal and insurance risks.

4. Regularly Audit Records:

   • Periodically review record-keeping practices to ensure compliance with RELRA and state commission rules.

5. Document Compliance Efforts:

   • Maintain written policies and procedures for archiving text messages and other communications to demonstrate good faith compliance.

Conclusion

In Pennsylvania, failing to archive and retain text messages that are part of real estate transactions exposes brokerages to significant E&O risks. Insurers may deny coverage for claims arising from non-compliance with state laws, lack of documentation, or allegations of negligence or misconduct. To protect against these risks, brokerages should implement comprehensive archiving solutions, establish clear communication policies, and ensure agents comply with retention requirements.

​

​

​

Sample: Text Archive for Real Estate

​

 

Mortgage Originators

In Pennsylvania, mortgage originators are subject to both federal and state laws that govern record retention, including requirements for archiving text messages if they pertain to business operations or mortgage transactions. These regulations ensure accountability, transparency, and compliance with legal standards in the mortgage industry.

1. Federal Requirements Applicable to Pennsylvania Mortgage Originators

Federal regulations provide the framework for record retention, which applies to mortgage originators operating in Pennsylvania. Key federal laws include:

A. Truth in Lending Act (TILA) and Regulation Z

• Mortgage originators must retain records that demonstrate compliance with disclosure and loan origination requirements for at least three years.

• Communications, including text messages, may need to be archived if they pertain to:

  • Loan terms.

  • Client agreements.

  • Disclosures provided to borrowers.

B. Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA) and Regulation X

• Requires retention of records related to settlement services and fees for five years.

• Text messages that involve fee agreements, settlement services, or disclosures may fall under these requirements.

C. Secure and Fair Enforcement for Mortgage Licensing Act (SAFE Act)

• Mandates that mortgage originators maintain accurate records to comply with licensing and regulatory requirements.

• Electronic communications like text messages may be subject to audit and examination.

D. CFPB's Record Retention Rules

• The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) enforces strict record-keeping requirements under various regulations, emphasizing that all forms of communication—including text messages—must be retained if they pertain to regulatory compliance or borrower interaction.

2. Pennsylvania-Specific Requirements

A. Pennsylvania Mortgage Licensing Act (7 Pa. C.S. Chapter 61)

• Mortgage originators and brokers licensed in Pennsylvania must maintain records related to their business operations for a period of four years.

• The Pennsylvania Department of Banking and Securities requires these records to be complete and accessible for examination.

B. Record-Keeping Rules

• Per state regulations, all communications related to mortgage origination, including text messages, must be archived if they involve:

  • Loan terms or agreements.

  • Disclosures to borrowers.

  • Client instructions or approvals.

C. Department of Banking and Securities Oversight

• The department conducts periodic examinations and audits to ensure compliance with record retention laws.

• Failure to produce records, including text messages, during an examination can result in fines, penalties, or license suspension.

3. Applicability of Text Messages

While Pennsylvania law does not explicitly mention "text messages," record retention laws broadly cover all forms of communication related to mortgage origination. Text messages that meet any of the following criteria must be archived:

• Contain terms or conditions of a mortgage loan.

• Provide information or disclosures to borrowers.

• Document interactions or agreements with clients.

4. Retention Periods

• Federal:

  • TILA and RESPA: At least three to five years depending on the type of record.

• State:

  • Pennsylvania law requires records to be retained for four years after the loan transaction is completed.

5. Risks of Non-Compliance

Failing to archive and retain text messages can lead to:

1. Regulatory Violations:

   • Fines or penalties from the Pennsylvania Department of Banking and Securities.

2. Legal Risks:

   • Weakened defense in disputes due to missing records.

3. Operational Challenges:

   • Inability to demonstrate compliance during audits or examinations.

6. Best Practices for Compliance

To comply with federal and Pennsylvania state laws, mortgage originators should:

1. Implement Text Message Archiving Solutions:

   • Use software designed to capture and store text messages securely for the required retention period.

   • Ensure archived messages are easily retrievable for audits or legal proceedings.

2. Train Employees:

   • Educate staff about the importance of retaining all communications, including text messages.

   • Provide clear guidelines on what constitutes a transaction-related message.

3. Establish Clear Policies:

   • Require all client-related communications to be conducted on approved platforms that support archiving.

   • Regularly update policies to align with changes in federal and state regulations.

4. Conduct Internal Audits:

   • Periodically review record-keeping practices to ensure all text messages and other records are properly archived.

5. Secure Client Data:

   • Follow data security protocols to protect archived messages from unauthorized access or breaches.

Conclusion

In Pennsylvania, mortgage originators are required to archive all communications, including text messages, if they pertain to loan terms, disclosures, or other transaction-related activities. These records must be retained for up to four years under state law and up to five years under federal regulations like RESPA. To avoid regulatory penalties and legal risks, mortgage originators should implement robust archiving systems, establish clear communication policies, and train employees on compliance requirements.